The Modern Auth Landscape
conceptThe map of how passwords, MFA, FIDO, WebAuthn, passkeys, and hardware keys actually fit together. Everything modern converges on one idea:
Never give the server a secret it can lose.
You do not need to be new to computers to be confused by this. The confusion exists because these technologies evolved incrementally, not coherently—independently, and never properly unified in documentation.
Modern authentication is built from layers, each solving a different problem:
- Identity—who are you claiming to be?
- Proof—how do you prove that claim?
- Transport—how does that proof travel safely?
- Enforcement—what limits abuse or theft?
Different technologies live at different layers; confusion happens when they get lumped together. How the pieces fit:
- Passwords → shared secrets (weak)
- OTP → layered defense (better)
- FIDO2/WebAuthn → cryptographic proof (strong)
- Passkeys → FIDO2 made usable
- Hardware keys → FIDO2 with physical enforcement
- SSH → cryptography before it was cool