SSH, Actually 100% signal, 0% noise.

The MFA Strength Ladder

concept
depth 3/3 − deeper + surface

A rough ordering of MFA methods from worst to best, ranked by one question: how hard is it for a motivated, competent attacker—who already knows your username—to successfully impersonate you?

The ladder, worst to best:

# Method Why it sits here
1 Email link Email accounts are often already compromised, logged in on many devices, and themselves protected by weak or reused credentials. If an attacker controls your email, this "factor" collapses entirely.
2 SMS code Vulnerable to SIM-swapping, carrier attacks, interception, and social engineering. The phone number—not the physical device—is the security anchor: a fundamental design flaw.
3 Authenticator app (TOTP) Codes are short-lived and not transmitted over the network, but still phishable and replayable—an attacker who tricks you into entering the code can immediately use it.
4 Enterprise time-based tokens Short validity windows, device management, logging, rapid revocation—but usually still code-based, so real-time phishing remains possible.
5 Biometrics (local) + WebAuthn The biometric doesn't authenticate you to the service—it unlocks a local authenticator, which proves identity cryptographically. The biometric never leaves the device.
6 Passkeys Passwords eliminated entirely; authentication by cryptographic signature, not shared secrets. Phishing-resistant, device-bound—but the platform controls creation, syncing, and recovery.
7 Hardware security keys Secrets never leave the hardware, authentication requires physical touch, attempts are rate-limited, and phishing fails because the device verifies the service before signing anything.

The ladder is really two ladders with a cliff between them. Rungs 1–4 are all code-based: something is generated, you type it, and whatever you can type, you can be tricked into typing. Rungs 5–7 are signature-based: nothing is typed, so phishing has nothing to capture.

As you move down the list:

  • Shared secrets disappear
  • Phishing stops working
  • Remote-only attacks fail
  • Physical presence becomes required

The strongest systems remove what can be copied, what can be guessed, and what can be tricked—and replace them with cryptographic proof tied to real hardware.